Amazon.com: Customer reviews: Clearly Herbal Gentle Rose Water Baby Wipes (12 Go Packs, 12 wipes per pack )

Top positive review

Manufacturer really needs to fix the smell of these

July 13, 2017

On both my babies I used reusable organic unbleached flannel wipes+home-made solution, and the following commercial brands: Honest, Pampers Sensitive, WaterWipes, Huggies, and Clearly Herbal brands. Below is my rating of wipes on various categories (on the scale of 1-to 5, where 5 is superior)

Toxicity
Home-made - 5
Joonya, Honest, Clearly Herbal, WaterWipes - 4
Pampers, Huggies -1

Prevents skin irritation
Home-made - 5 - the only ones that consistently cause zero irritation, and repair the irritation caused by other wipes or diapers.
Joonya, Honest, WaterWipes- 4.5 (no issues for a few days)
Clearly Herbal - 4 (can go for 1-2 days)
Pampers, Huggies- 3 (okay for occasional 1-2 uses)

How well they separate when pulled from the tub
Joonya, Honest, Clearly Herbal, Pampers - 5
Home-made -4
WaterWipes, Huggies - 2

Smell
Home-made, Joonya, WaterWipes - 5 (none)
Pampers, Honest - 4 (pleasant)
Huggies -3
Clearly Herbal - 1 (stink)

How well they clean on the first pass (relates to texture, which 'grabs' the particulate)
Home-made, Joonya, Honest - 5 (1-2 wipes for an average poop amount)
WaterWipes, Clearly Herbal, Pampers, Huggies -2 (need 3-4 to get the job done)

Ability to stay moist without drying out half-way (NOTE: I use wipes warmer that accelerates drying out)
Home-made, Joonya, Honest - 5
WaterWipes, Clearly Herbal -4
Pampers -3
Huggies -1

Overall, of the commercial wipes, Joonya and Honest are my favorite. They do not beat my home-made wipes and solution in my opinion, but are the second best. WaterWipes and Clearly Herbal are in the 'like' category, and Pampers and Huggies are in the 'avoid' list.

9 people found this helpful

Top critical review

See all 15 critical reviews›

love dogs

Fewer wipes for nearly same price, what the heck?!

April 23, 2015

3 stars b/c these wipes are awesome. Should be 5. But for some reason, a case is now 12 packs of 64 wipes (768 total) vs. 12 packs of 80 wipes (960) total. This switch is recent, within the last few months. I didn't notice until the second case of smaller packs. I was getting angry at my son's school for going through them too quickly. I just at down to review my past orders of the 80 ct packs and now 64 count packs. The prices are a little all over the place, but I was getting the 80 ct pack cases for $49.99, and today the case of 64 ct ones is $47.99 (the case I got in early April was $42.99, why the $5 jump?)--does that seem right when you're getting almost 200 fewer wipes?!?! I don't care if these things are woven by angels and saturated with water from a magical stream, that's a rip off. I think I'll be fast-tracking my son to potty training so I don't need to take out a second mortgage for wipes. I'd leave a 1 star review for how I feel right now, but that would be wrong as these are very nice wipes otherwise. So if you have unlimited funds and a high tolerance for questionable business practices, I'd recommend these.

7 people found this helpful

Sort by

Filter by

Showing 1-5 of 5 reviews(4 star). Clear filter

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

Sasha Cannon

Manufacturer really needs to fix the smell of these

July 13, 2017

Size: Case of 12Verified Purchase

9 people found this helpful

Helpful

0Comment

Amy M.

These smell fantastic and don't have a greasy feel

February 24, 2018

Size: 72 Count case of 12Verified Purchase

These smell fantastic and don't have a greasy feel, but I find I need twice as much as regular wipes to get the job done.

Helpful

0Comment

Katalin

I really like these wipes

March 22, 2015

Size: Case of 12

I really like these wipes, however, like some other reviewers I'm really disappointed in the smaller packaging. These wipes were already fairly expensive, and now they are even more so. I think I'll be looking into some other natural wipes to replace these. Unfortunately, I hated the smell of both the seventh generation and babyganics wipes.

Helpful

0Comment

Georgia

Amazing!

April 15, 2018

Size: 72 Count case of 12Verified Purchase

The only thing I don't like is that it's hard to only take one wipe out at a time. They sometimes stick together. Everything else is great! My daughter loves them. She loves to play with them and even tried to eat them. They smell amazing and get the job done.

Helpful

11 comment

Anna

Great wipes.

May 29, 2015

Size: Case of 12Verified Purchase

Like these wipes a lot as a natural and safe wipe for my kiddos... though the scent is very strong. (It's not a bad smell, but they're surprisingly fragrant.) Jackson Reece wipes are our favorite, but I think these ones are a better price. I do recommend.

Helpful

0Comment