Finally! I found a dry food my kitty absolutely loves. Every morning she hops up to her perch and calls for her morning kibble. It's a bit on the expensive side but she likes it much better than Orijen which was about the same price. Her coat and eyes are noticeably shinier and she seems to be more active. I highly recommend Instinct Ultimate for finicky cats and for general well-being and health of both you and your fur baby!
Cats love it. Their fur has never been softer. Seems to be good for their weight and health since both are 19 years old thus the five star rating. The dislike is the subscription. They offer every other month but when you think you have it set up, it reverts to monthly which is too much for skinny old cats. I may have to start manually ordering but it looks like I may have to get an Amazon rep to help me terminate the subscription since I have not seen that choice.
Update: This is great food when my cats will eat it, but about 1 out of 3 bags both my cats will not touch. They smell it and refuse to eat it. WHY? I just opened a 10 pound bag and both of my cats will not eat it. I then placed the exact same food from another bag next to it and they went right for it. This happens over and over again.
On closer inspection you can see it has a slightly different color and texture. Even smells different enough for me to notice.
I can't keep wasting my money on this.
___________ I have an older extremely picky cat that actually likes this food. This cat is so picky I have problems keeping him from being underweight. He also tires of eating the same thing for more than a few days. With Instinct he seems to like it a lot longer before wanting something different. Most foods he tires of after 2-3 days but he'll eat Instinct for about 5-7 days before tiring of it. And he is happy to eat it again after about a week.
I set up an auto-shipment of this food, and when it gets here, my cat will literally follow me around while I hold unpack the box. She's in love with it. I've also noticed an improvement in her attitude and her fur. Seems to be doing the job, even if it's a little pricey.